The Scarecrow Queen


Title: The Scarecrow Queen

Author: Melinda Salisbury

Series: The Sin-Eater’s Daughter, #3

Publisher: Scholastic Press

Release Date: March 2nd 2017


Five Stars

The final battle is coming…

As the Sleeping Prince tightens his hold on Lormere and Tregellan, the net closes in on the ragged band of rebels trying desperately to defeat him. Twylla and Errin are separated, isolated, and running out of time. The final battle is coming, and Aurek will stop at nothing to keep the throne forever…

Explosive, rich and darkly addictive, this is the stunning conclusion to Mel Salisbury’s internationally best-selling trilogy that began withΒ The Sin Eater’s Daughter.

– Blurb courtesy of

This review may contain spoilers for previous book(s) in the series.

My Thoughts On…

…The Plot

“I am tired of running away from everything.
I want to be like Errin. Like Nia. Like Sister Hope. I want to be the girl who fought a golem, the girl who slammed her hands on a table and told a room full of powerful women that I was going to fight, and to hell with them.”

At the end of The Sleeping Prince it seemed like the battle was over before it had begun. Aurek sent his Silver Knight to the conclave and slaughtered the men, women and children there. He took Errin back to Lormere and although Twylla is still out there she is alone, and without an apothecary to make the potion needed to send the Sleeping Prince back to sleep.

Twylla knows she can’t stay hidden in the conclave forever. She needs to keep going; for Errin, for Merek, for Silas. Reuniting with the few survivors left alive Twylla, Sister Hope, Nia and Kirin start their journey to Tressalyn, but before they can reach it they discover the Sleeping Prince has beat them there, and that it may be too late for their short-lived rebellion.

“Look at me.”
I obey him because if I don’t, he’ll make me with his simulacrum. Or he’ll kill me…So I lift my head and meet his golden eyes as steadily as I can. The moment I do he nods in victory and loses interest in me.

Meanwhile in the castle under the control of the Sleeping Prince Errin struggles to stay alive and well. Holding a simulacrum that grants him complete control over her Errin can’t fight back the way she wants, and with Aurek holding the lives of her mother and Silas over her head she won’t do anything to risk them. Still she doesn’t give in. Working in secret with Merek, who is alive and hiding as a servant in the castle, Errin commits small acts of rebellion waiting for something to change, for some advantage she can use to either escape and reunite with Twylla or take down Aurek for good.

As Errin stands against Aurek in his home in any way she can and Twylla starts building her army and her resistance the Sleeping Prince works to strength his hold over Lormere and Tregellan. Errin and Twylla know they only have one chance to take down Aurek, but first they need to find one another onceΒ more.

I feel like this series has always been somewhat understated when it comes to action. There is an incredible plot, incredible characters and an incredible world but it’s a slow build to come to its peak. The Scarecrow Queen is no different. The acts of rebellion Twylla and Errin commit are small, but all come together to undermine Aurek. They both know they only have one shot, and it is more than their lives at risk, so they can’t afford to rush and make any stupid mistakes.

…The Characters

“I was Daunen Embodied. I was hope. To the people of Lormere, I am the living representation of triumph over extreme adversity.”

Twylla has to learn to become a leader in this book. In The Sin-Eater’s Daughter she was content to follow the pattern of her days that the Queen had set out before her, and even after she discovered the way she had been manipulated she didn’t want to fight back she just wanted to run away from it all. In The Scarecrow Queen, with Errin and Silas gone and most of the Conclave slaughtered, it falls on Twylla to be the leader, as Daunen Embodied she represents hope for the people of Lormere.

Her development in this book allowed Twylla to reach her full potential. She is scared in the beginning, lost without anyone standing beside her, but as the story commences we see her become a real leader to her people, like she promised Errin she could be in The Sleeping Prince.

“The Tower of Attrition,” he says. “That what this will be known as. A place to break the spirits of mares that run wild. Because you will break, Errin. Or you will die.”

Errin has always been a fighter but in the castle, under Aurek’s control, she needs to learn to bend to his will somewhat before he takes his anger out on the people she loves. Errin’s body is being used against her, but her mind is still her own and she uses it to resist the Sleeping Prince however she can. Despite being in a dangerous situation Errin is still doing everything she can to help Twylla from the inside, refusing to flee the castle without Silas and her mother, no matter what Aurek does to her.

Family has always been important to Errin, something evident from the moment we were introduced to her in the second book, but after everything her brother has done she can’t forgive him for siding with Aurek and putting her and their mother in danger. Lief has been a complicated character from the beginning, because of all the treachery and double crossing it’s very hard to tell what side he is on. He respects Aurek and does his bidding but at the same time he’s like Errin in that family is important to him. He clearly believes, however misguided, that the castle is the safest place for her and their mother.

“Do you really think Twylla would forgive me if I left you behind?” He takes a deep breath and stretches. “If I go, then you’re coming with me. When I go you’re coming with me. You and Silas.”
I smile. “Agreed.”

There isn’t a lot of romance in this book. Silas and Errin are both separated from one another in Aurek’s castle, though Silas is never far from Errin’s thoughts and never far from the Sleeping Prince’s threats. There is a little more development to Merek and Twylla’s romance though. In the first book the love triangle between Twylla, Lief and Merek only focused on Twylla and Lief; this book brings Merek back into the picture, only we don’t just see him as a love interest but as his own character as well.

Despite everything Merek still fights for the throne and his people. He keeps his head down and hides in plain sight right under the Sleeping Prince’s nose, but it isn’t enough. He wants to take the battle further and get rid of Aurek for good, especially when he hears what is happening to his people. Merek can’t help but feel guilty, for losing the throne and for everything the Sleeping Prince has done, but it’s clear his people still love him.

…The Setting

“I won’t hide in the woods anymore. We’re making for the East Mountains and we’re leaving at noon. There’s a refuge there that will hold us all. I want us there within the week, and ready to begin fighting back. It’s time the Sleeping Prince learned that the dawn will rise. The dawn will always rise.”
I wait for no comment, sweeping through them and back to the camp.
I know they follow me now.

There wasn’t a lot made of the setting in this book, but it didn’t feel shallow or two dimensional. A lot of work went into the world building in the first and second books which allowed this third one to focus on the battle, focus on the plot, and focus the characters themselves. There was still more to discover about Lormere and Tregellan though; we saw more of Aurek’s past, more of the Alchemists, and more of Twylla and her families role in the whole situation. The Sin-Eaters Daughter is a story that focused on the world and the characters, The Scarecrow Queen however chooses to focus on the plot, stepping back and letting the world it developed in the first two books remain in the background a little more.

Overall this has been an amazing series, and I love how it ended with The Scarecrow Queen. It was left open, there is definitely a lot left to be explored in terms of all the characters still alive, but it fit with the tone of the book. The Scarecrow Queen doesn’t give us all the answers, but leaves the space for us to discover them for ourselves.

What did you think of The Scarecrow Queen? Was it a favourite of yours or could you just not get into the story? Let me know.

17 thoughts on “The Scarecrow Queen

  1. So I obvs skimmed this but I have good news! A friend of mine for my birthday ordered this from BD! So I’ll be able to read it! Yay!
    You know, I won a Maximum POP giveaway for a signed copy of Michael Grant’s Silver Stars, and I needed a U.K. address stat, so I asked Tiffthebooknerd for hers. I wish you had been on Twitter so I could have messaged you instantly! We need to talk on the regs, yo! 😘

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Well obviously, you definitely want to go into this book as blind as possible, with no expectations for how the story will go. But oh that’s great news, the sooner the better right?
      Oh congratulations on the giveaway, and that’s a good thing about the address. Hopefully I’ll have a Twitter soon, I have Bookstagram (again) and GR on my list for next though! πŸ™‚ ❀


  2. I absolutely adore ambiguous endings, so that ending sounds like a dream. I’m so glad that you enjoyed this series! I’ll definitely have to pick them up sometime this year! πŸ˜€

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Another one that’s high up on my TBR/anticipated reads but haven’t yet gotten round to reading! We have very similar reading tastes ahaha πŸ˜€ Again, I’m so glad you loved this. Your reviews are great, they build my excitement up every time!

    Liked by 1 person

  4. This is interesting! Using the first two books to build the world and have the third one focus on the battle. I haven’t read that many series to know if it’s an efficient way to tell a story. In fact, not having “anymore” world-building sounds weird, but then again it seems all right when you have a pretty good knowledge of the setting and lore! Great review! πŸ˜€

    – Lashaan

    Liked by 1 person

    1. It worked for me with this series but I do think there are a few people who would say differently. Simply because the first book is all about the character development and the world building there is little action in it.
      Oh there was still world building in this book, but not as much. Everything had already been built up so as I was reading I knew all the information about the setting that was dropped in in casual conversation between characters.
      Thanks Lashaan. πŸ™‚

      Liked by 1 person

  5. A slow burning in the genre might disappoint but I love the sound of small actions building something big. I’m glad the series was a good one πŸ™‚ I’m not so keen on open endings, I like it when I know exactly everything, haha!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I think this is the kind of series that either works for people or doesn’t, mainly because of the plot and the slow burn throughout the whole series.
      The series was great in my opinion, and I know what you mean. I do wish there had been at least one more chapter in this book to wrap everything up a little more. πŸ™‚


  6. Ahhh I already had this on my TBR after reading your first two reviews on the two previous books, but I am so glad to hear the third book was so good! This series sounds amazing, I definitely want to pick it up. 😍❀ Lovely review!

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.