ARC Review: Book of Fire

Book of Fire


Title: Book of Fire

Author: Michelle Kenney

Series: Book of Fire, #1

Publisher: HQ Digital

Release Date: August 27th 2017

Rating:

Three Stars

Life outside the domes is not possible. At least that’s what Insiders are told. Twins Eli and Talia shouldn’t exist. They’re Outsiders.

Their home is a secret. Their lives are a secret. Arafel is a secret.

An unexpected forest raid forces Talia into a desperate mission to rescue her family while protecting the sacred book of Arafel from those who would use it as a weapon. As Talia and her life long friend Max enter the dome, she makes some unexpected discoveries, and allies, in the form of rugged Insider August, that will change the course of her life forever.

She’ll stop at nothing to save her family but will she sacrifice her heart in the process?

The Fire Sermon meets Gladiator in this brilliant YA debut.

– Blurb courtesy of goodreads.com

I received an ARC of this book free from YA HQ. It in no way affects my views on Book of Fire.

My Thoughts On…

…The Plot

“Sometimes I would climb to the top of the Great Oak – the one that had somehow survived the devastating effects of the biochemical warfare – and stare out at the impenetrable, domed expanse of bright white that climbed and dipped as far as the eye could see.”

When nuclear war destroyed the earth the domes were the only place humanity could survive, but Talia’s existence throws that theory out the window. Talia is an Outsider, she lives in a hidden village in the forests that have overtaken the cities, living off the crops her people grow and hunting for food. Arafel has an uneasy truce with the domes, in return for a few specimen from the outside they will be left alone. The Outsiders remain free to live their lives without fear of attack and the people in the domes remain closed off, ignorant to the fact that there the earth outside is once again able to sustain life.

That is until the Sweepers start moving close to their village and a group including Talia’s brother, Eli, her best friend, Max, and her grandpa is sent out to discover more. Determined to help protect them, knowing her grandpa is frail, Talia follows in secret and when an unexpected raid takes Eli and Talia’s grandpa, unwilling to return home without them, Talia breaks in to the domes with Max to rescue her family.

“There was a stony silence while I mentally assessed the chances of making it out of his unit and finding Max, Grandpa, and Eli in this vast, genetically warped and technologically advanced world alone. They were not encouraging.”

Inside the dome is a different place, Talia is quickly separated from Max and lost in this new world where nothing is familiar. She is quickly found by August, a Commander General which puts him at the right hand of Octavia, the head of the domes. Talia isn’t sure she can trust August but she can’t save Eli and her grandpa on her own, and with no clue where Max is she needs all the help she can get.

However Octavia’s plan for Talia’s grandpa is not what she thought. Octavia wants to Book of Arafel, something her grandpa has kept hidden for years, and something he has now passed down to Talia.

When I first read the blurb for this book, particularly the part about the insiders living in domes, my mind went to Under the Never Sky. These two books are completely different but Book of Fire has a really intriguing concept. More of a dystopian story with a mix of fantasy I really enjoyed the plot, and loved Talia’s character because she’s the kind of heroine we need more in YA fiction. However I couldn’t get behind the world building, also there was a love triangle in this book which I saw coming a mile away and which I definitely wasn’t a fan of at all.

…The Characters

“Feral. That’s what they called us. Those who knew of us. It was ignorance bred from fear—fear of life on the outside, and fear of us.”

Talia is an incredible heroine; she is strong without being reckless and smart without being arrogant. When she sees her brother and he grandpa taken by the Sweepers she doesn’t hesitate before going after them; determined to free them, to bring her grandpa home and keep her brother safe the way she has her whole life. At the same time though she doesn’t expect anyone to put their own lives in danger for her mission. She keeps telling Max to return to Arafel, scared of losing him as well, and she doesn’t trust blindly. Even though August offers to help her free Eli and her grandpa Talia doesn’t fully trust someone that close to Octavia.

Family is important to Talia. She lost their father a few years ago, and ever since then her mother has always been fearful of what could happen to her children when they are out of her sight. That thought is what drives Talia when she thinks of how her mother could feel if she returns home without Eli, or later if neither of them ever return home. Eli and Talia have a close bond; Eli doesn’t speak and can’t hear and as such Talia is very protective of him, but Eli isn’t a weak character. He’s just as capable as his sister but in a different way.

I turned to August in confusion. “It’s not Max; they’ve got the wrong man!” I cried, unsure whether to feel worried or relieved.
“Excellent. I didn’t think he was much of a choice for a boyfriend,” he returned.
“You know Max isn’t my boyfriend!” I snapped.

The love triangle I mentioned earlier was one I wasn’t a fan of. It was the very definition of a love triangle trope; main character is suddenly caught between two boys, one is a childhood friend and the other is the newcomer in her life she isn’t quite sure she should trust but does anyway. On its own I could have got behind Talia’s relationship with Max, or her relationship with August, because there would have been more room to develop it. However squeezing the development of both relationships into this one book left me unable to connect with either of them, and most of the time I was just thinking; ‘really? Again?’.

“Her words struck a discord in my head. August’s true motivations were as unclear as ever, and Aelia’s acidity only made my suspicions worse.”

There was also another trope in this book I couldn’t stand; girl hate. When Talia first meets Aelia the other girl is instantly standoffish and abrasive, and as the book continues their interactions never seem to improve. Talia doesn’t trust Aelia, which considering where they are and the fact that Aelia is an Insider is understandable, but when you take into account the fact that August is not only an Insider but a Commander General and Talia trusts him, it’s less understandable.

When it comes to the characters in this book I liked them all individually, and thought they were well developed, but it was their interactions and relationships with one another that felt lacking.

…The Setting

“The scientific team, led by Octavia, looked back over history for a model civilisation to emulate. The success of the ancient Roman Empire stood out, and it didn’t take long for the terminology to follow. Unfortunately, over time more of their…practices have also been adopted.”
His tone has grown dark and I shuddered. I was certain Isca Pantheon was hiding secrets.”

I have mixed feelings about the world building in this book. On one hand I really liked the concept; the idea of humanity recovering in domes to protect them from the after effects of a nuclear war, the idea that outside life had recovered but the general population were being kept in the dark. Talia and Max come into the domes from the outside and find themselves in a complete foreign world where life has been modelled on the Roman Empire, the perfect example of a successful civilisation in Octavia’s mind. However that’s when things got complicated. While it was all well written and well developed the author mixed science with Greek myths and it just didn’t work for me, it felt like two completely different worlds being crammed together like mismatching puzzle piece. The book was well developed but in my opinion it wasn’t well developed enough to connect the science and the myths.


Dystopian books are never going to be a favourite of mine, and while Book of Fire was a good read – the plot hooked me so I was always interested in what would happen next, and the characters were individually well developed – there were just too many downsides. I couldn’t get behind the world building of the characters relationships with one another, and for me those are two important aspects in any book.

What did you think of Book of Fire? Was it a favourite of yours or could you just not get into the story? Let me know.

All quotes have been taken from an ARC and may differ in the final publication.

Advertisements

12 thoughts on “ARC Review: Book of Fire

  1. The cover is so pretty! This made me just think of The 100 in a way! Although it could be good, might give it a miss – I feel the same as you with love triangles – been there, done that – and it doesn’t sound like it develops very well. Great review!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Oh I haven’t read/seen The 100 (I do want to read/watch it though) so I can’t really say if this book is similar. Book of Fire was a good story but yeah for me the love triangle let it done and if you’re feeling ‘been there, done that’ with them I can’t say I’d recommend this book.
      Thanks Lindsey. 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

      1. The 100 was one of the rare occasions where I preferred the show, but that mainly came down to it being aimed at a slightly older audience whereas I found the book a touch immature in several places. Thanks – not going to get drawn in by the pretty cover then 😉

        Liked by 1 person

      2. I always try and read the books before seeing the show, but I guess I’ve got to try it for myself. One day I’ll get around to it. 🙂
        That’s all right – I know all too well about being drawn in by pretty covers only to be disappointed by the actual book.

        Like

  2. Oh, characters and world building are definitely two very important aspects of a novel that I value as well! I’m sorry to hear about the more disappointing areas of this book, especially after having a relatively interesting concept. The love triangle already seems like something I’d be bothered by, not to mention the girl hate!! How frustrating. Thank you for this thorough review, as always! ❤

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Yeah unfortunately they were the two areas that let this book down which is a shame because I thought it was a really interesting concept. It could have been much between you know?
      I knew there was going to be a love triangle, I can’t say I was surprised by it but I was a little irritated.
      Thanks Analee, I’m glad you liked this review. 🙂 ❤

      Liked by 1 person

  3. Awww man.. Dreadful love triangles. Sucks that it literally hindered the experience and development of any of the two potential relationships. World-building fantasy novels is definitely key and I know you put this at the top of your check-list, so I’m sorry to hear this one failed you! It’s nice that you were still able to enjoy it though. Great review, Beth! 😀

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I’m never going to be a massive fan of love triangles. Some I don’t mind because it makes sense for the characters development, but that didn’t seem to be the case in Book of Fire.
      Yeah world building is the number one thing I look for. It was well written in Book of Fire, I can say that, but I couldn’t connect with it or believe in it you know, which is just as important.
      Thanks Lashaan. 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

  4. Oh, I read “girl hate” and got angry. 😂 GIRL HATE IS SO HORRIBLE. Obviously there’s going to be SOME girl hate in books, but a lot of girls are actually super supportive to other girls! And then there’s no term “boy hate” which makes me wonder… 🤔 Anyways, I’m sorry this had girl hate in it! And I’m sorry you couldn’t really get into the book — the dystopian genre is really hit or miss. Great review, though! 😊

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Yeah it really is, and to be honest it’s probably one of my most hated tropes in YA books. I’d rather see strong female friendships but it seems like they’re kind of lacking you know? No there never seems to be boy hate, kind of interesting when you think about it. Not that I’d wanna see boy hate in books either way.
      Thanks May, yeah guess this one was more miss than hit for me. 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s